Guest Stars Conor Leslie as Mars Demosthenes Chrysan as Detective Matthews Nicholas J. Coleman as Ronnie Co Starring Tom Day as Carl Jeremy Dash as Billy Qurrat Ann Kadwani as Newscaster Joshua Dela Cruz as Box Office Attendant Michael Silberblatt as Projectionist Eddie K. Robinson as Movie Patron Yinka Adeboyeku as NYPD Officer Mike McGowan as Kal Vazquez Haaron Hines as Jeff Andy Do as Young Usher