Guest Stars Deborah Ann Woll as Jessica Hamby Kristin Bauer van Straten as Pamela Swynford De Beaufort Todd Lowe as Terry Bellefleur Michael McMillian as Steve Newlin Michelle Forbes as Maryann Forrester Mehcad Brooks as "Eggs" Benedict Talley Adam Leadbeater as Karl Danielle Sapia as Maudette Pickens Michael Bofshever as Orry Dawson Co Starring John Rezig as Deputy Kevin Ellis Laurel Weber as Lisa Fowler Alec Zbornak as Coby Fowler Tess Alexandra Parker as Rosie Daniel Quentin Rebert as Puppeteer Bernhard Eichholz as Puppeteer Stacie Rippy as Cindy Marshall