Guest Stars Sherri Saum as Karla Benjamin Flores Jr. as Freddy Erica Sullivan voices Fairy Heath Koerschgen as Councilman Weeks Co Starring Eric Newsome as Mailman Dave Skyler Verity as Graham Tee Dennard as Townsfolk #1 Tim Eulich as Vincent Michael Lewis as Townsfolk #4 Lorraine Bahr as Penelope Emily Sahler as Sylvia Luke Spencer Wyngarden as Timmy Andrew York as Mark Tyler Saum as Dante