Guest Stars Amanda Foreman as Meghan Rotundi Ian Gomez as Javier Clemente Quintata Dash Mihok as Lynn McKennan Eddie McClintock as Ryan Crane Amy Hathaway as Nicole Drew Pillsbury as Swim Coach Nathan Anderson as Alex Anne DeSalvo as Lawyer Co Starring Spencer Beglarian as Samuel Anna Garduno as Waitress Uncredited Janeane Garofalo voices Sally Reardon