Guest Stars Daniel Sauli as Tommy Longo Mustafa Shakir as Big Mike Andrea-Rachel Parker as Bernice Kim Director as Shay Method Man as Rodney Ralph Macchio as Officer Haddix Jamie Neumann as Ashley David Krumholtz as Harvey Wasserman Don Harvey as Danny Flanagan Kayla Foster as Barbara Garry Pastore as Matty "The Horse" Shaun O'Hagan as Lieutenant Gerald Sweeney Saul Stein as Marty Hodas Tariq Trotter as Jerry Love David Aaron Baker as James Schuster Stephen Singer as Judge Aaron Bressler