Special Guest Stars Alia Shawkat as Lila Guest Stars Rob Huebel as Len Zackary Arthur as Zack Molly Bernard as Younger Shelly John Getz as Donald Ashley Silverman as Ella Jenny O'Hara as Bryna Elisha Henig as Young Simon Bill Wise as August Emily Robinson as Young Ali Kelsey Reinhardt as Young Sarah Tate Hanyok as Younger Bryna Alison MacKay as Rosalie Wren T. Brown as Herbert Michelle Gardner as Danielle Bashir Naim as Simon Wayne Federman as Jerry Luisa Szillies as Liesel Dalton Rich as Young Josh
