Guest Stars Samantha Soule as Charlotte Temple Audrey Moore as Sarah Doyle Adam David Thompson as Gatz Brown Matthew Dennis Lewis as Donnie Devlin Kayli Carter as Sadie Rose Luke Robertson as Bill Chick Rio Alexander as Bud Ledbetter Keith Jardine as Dyer Howe Joe Pingue as Alonzo Bunker Travis Hammer as John Doe Samuel Marty as Truckee Marie Wagenman as Trudy McNue Tess Frazer as Callie Dunne Justin Welborn as Floyd Wilson Russell Dennis Lewis as Daryl Devlin Randy Oglesby as Asa Leopold Brian Lee Franklin as Amos Green Sophia Silver as Saloon Sophia Michael Earl Reid as Barney Mutz John Lawlor as Elmer Knowland Courtney Cunningham as Mae Michael Horse as Chief Narrienta Rachel Singer as Betsy Malcolm Gets as J.B. Sloan Patrick Carlyle as Dr. Elijah Graham Zack Duhame as Creed Man Executioner Kayleigh Maes as 17 Year Old Girl John C. Cooke as Cook's Posse #1 Monty Stuart as Cook's Posse #2 Nick Breeden as Fireman William H. Colley as Train Engineer