Guest Stars Jack Conley as Metro Detective Danny Sportelli Lauren Stamile as Metro P.D. Detective Michelle Lane Carter MacIntyre as Benjamin "Benny" Sitano, Junior Susan Blakely as Dr. Cadence Darwin Travis Wester as Metro P.D. Detective Miles Higgins Coley Speaks as Omar Nitro Amy Letcher as Fiona Co Starring Adam Faison as Alastair Alexander Davis as Landon Pottorf Tyler Lueck as Man Who Proposes Megan Sheenan as Woman Who Says No
