Guest Stars James Handy as Officer O'Neil Bruce A. Young as Officer Matlin Co Starring Abigail Mavity as Abigail Charlie Stewart as Charlie Rolando Molina as Dad #2 Jennie Fahn as Mom #2 Ellen Ratner as Miss Suskind Shawn Huang as Kenny Richard Hoyt Miller as Red Headed Dad Dylan Capannelli as Randy Scotty Cox as Lenny Elizabeth Anne Smith as Mom #1