Guest Stars Wakeema Hollis as Monica Colby Brianna Brown as Claudia Blaisdel Nick Wechsler as Matthew Blaisdel Michael Beach as Police Chief Aaron Stansfield Dave Maldonado as Willy Miller Co Starring Valerie Jane Parker as Reporter #1 Gissette Valentin as Reporter #2 Anthony Nguyen as FBI Agent Leland L. Jones as Minister Chris Greene as Officer Reed Chandra Michaels as Marla Bicks Thompson Blake as Lawyer Tony Leon as Reporter #3