Guest Stars Miriam Flynn as Sister Helen Steve Larson as Reggie Daniel Farber as Mitchell Jarrett Lennon as Croyce Co Starring Keaton Savage as Young Sean J.B. Gaynor as Young Eddie Jessica Stier as Ashley Dean Cudworth as T.J.'s Customer #3 Michael C. Alexander as Customer #1 Chris Flanders as Customer #2 Bart Tangredi as T.J.'s Customer #2 Robert M. Koch as T.J.'s Customer #1 Scott Rabinowitz as Bartender Steven Porfido as Game Room Customer #1 Uncredited Donal Logue as Paddy Finnerty
