Guest Stars Robert Patrick as Reverend Eliakim Phelps Bethany Anne Lind as Sarah Nicholson Phelps Steven Sean Garland as Abner Phelps Tom Thon as Dr. Isaac Bristol Daniel Thomas May as Austin Phelps Co Starring Maddie Nichols as Anna Phelps Ryan Homchick as Alex Le Gros Neal Genys as Henry Phelps Anna Lou House as Mrs. Coombs
