Guest Stars Tim Bagley as Toby Pearson Andy Daly as Officer Chuck Dorgan Jonathan Togo as Handsome Preppie James Urbaniak as Carl Fromm Co Starring Sawyer Shipman as Tristan Lily Mae Silverstein as Anna Jailen Bates as Levi Doreen Fox Loughlin as Mrs. Willis Makana Say as Max Claire Nicole Titman as Alyssa Brian O'Connor as Caller
