Guest Stars Michael Cerveris as Professor Pyg Christopher Convery as Martin Gordon Winarick as Tommy Elliot Co Starring Kelcy Griffin as Detective Harper Andrew Sellon as Mr. Penn / Mr. Scarface Joanne Nosuchinsky as Reporter Joe Avellar as Reporter #2 Ken Straus as Desk Sergeant Joy Sudduth as Reporter #1 Jon Shaver as Rich Guest Frank Alfano, Jr. as Waiter #1 Omar Torres as Grover Jack Sochet as On-Looker