Guest Stars Jake Epstein as Chuck Russink Reed Diamond as John Forstell Dillon Casey as Detective Blakey Emma Bell as Carey Morgan Kristoffer Polaha as David Sheridan Jim Piddock as Dr. Rune Co Starring Nneka Elliott as Reporter Carla Green Elana Dunkelman as Natalie Dan Duran as Reporter Joel Estevez Zahir Gilani as Reporter #3 Michasha Armstrong as Flotus Driver Krystyna Ellis-Kapitan as Caroler #5 Hannah Sota-Yermane as Caroler #4 Sasha Pulker as Caroler #3 Chloe Poch-Goldin as Caroler #6 Seth Mohan as Non-Descript Man Hannah Grace Scott as Caroler #2 Alyna Ross as Caroler #1 McKenna Otter as Caroler (Freckles) Jay Davis as SUV #1 SS Gary Augustynek as Veteran Andrew Bigelow as Ken Grissom Hannah Levinson as A Young Girl James Coburn as Remy Lucas Birgitte Solem as Secretary Anne Pilson