Guest Stars Layla Alizada as Simza Ranko Leah Gibson as Sylvia Haverford Noah Bean as Foster Hilburn Aasif Mandvi as Pazhani "Paz" Kapoor Bart Braverman as Josip "Big Jim" Turner Rowena King as Maggie Sexton-Templesmith Jordan Feldman as Marty Roberto Sanchez as Jaime Cordero Erica Gimpel as Agent Sims Rhea Seehorn as Ms. Haverford Wil Deusner as Young Charlie Leah McKendrick as Liz Co Starring Callie Hope Haverda as Lala Marks Lorrie Odom as Sharon Caleb Z. Smith as Li'l Tony Ranko Amanda Jaros as Drug Mule Tatum Bailey as Young Sylvia Willow Geer as Staff Member Caroline Kwan as Retreat Seeker Roberta Bassin as Aunt Betsy Chris Warner as Prison Guard Peter Arpesella as Toto