Guest Stars Christopher O'Shea as Noah Sager Marlee Matlin as Mrs. Finley Michael O'Keefe as Richard Tremblay Brandon Victor Dixon as Chris Morgan Kelvin Han Yee as Detective Ted Rogers Portia Cue as Victoria Morgan Kate Easton as Leah Hartzell Zachary Booth as Darren Hartzell Co Starring Michael Banks Repeta as Harrison Hartzell