Guest Stars Tracie Thoms as FBI Agent Maya Kennedy Lee Tergesen as Mel Foster Kelly Rutherford as Paula Lannigan Jordan Bridges as Neil Pruitt Tracy Middendorf as Sr. Helen Ross Christopher McDonald as Pastor Marcia DeBonis as Prison Social Worker Jesse C. Boyd as Kevin Spencer Lana Young as Detective Michele Hodiak Co Starring Danica Ketcham as Beth Foster Chloi Zi as Cassie Breann Couch as TBD Kate Bond as Melanie Spencer Eric Mendenhall as TBD Jack Landry as Justin Fromin Ashlee Payne as Jenny Fromin Scott Schaffer as TBD John Walpole as Dennis Cargill Marty Terry as Old Lady