Guest Stars Michael Chernus as Kyle Elizabeth Reaser as Andi Parker Sawyers as Jason Lindsay Burdge as Amy Co Starring Lucas VonKampen as Allen Phil Ridarelli as Tom Craig Butta as Frank Bruno Wendy Mateo as Playwright Natasha Forouzannia as Masseuse Suzanne Adent as Perry Sam Guinan-Nyhart as Justin Dustin Defa as Therapist William Bungeroth as Play Director Carmen Molina as Play Actor 1 Brian Zielnicki as Bartender