Guest Stars Peter Gwinn as Andy Judy Greer as Gretchen Danielle MacDonald as Grace Co Starring Jacqueline Toboni as Jo Tim Kazurinsky as Father Timothy Marissa Banker as Bible Study Teen #2 Joette Waters as Homeless Person #3 David Woolley as Homeless Person #2 Kebin L. Carr as Homeless Person #1 Michael Saguto as Bible Study Teen #1 Sophie Traub as Stephanie Lillie Cummings as Grace's Friend #2 Khloe Janel as Grace's Friend #1 Alex Ross Perry as Mr. Pope Brooke Breit as Bank Worker Miriam Moss as Grace's Friend #3 Dre Marquis as Grace's Friend #4 Jordan Brodess as Jake
