Guest Stars Amy Hohn as Judge Sally Volk Ron Canada as Judge Miles Skurnick Marin Ireland as Maya Whitbeck Chloë Levine as Jemma Whitbeck Nadia Dajani as Thalia Macera Matthew Humphreys as ADA Pappas Chester Jones III as Jeb Rooney Johnathan Tchaikovsky as Ryan Macera Satchel Eden Bell as Cassie Williams Co Starring Laura Spencer as Jemma's Friend Florence Regina as Jury Foreman Dave T. Koenig as Simon Patrick Cann as Guard Malikha Mallette as Reporter Franca Vercelloni as Juror #2 Vishaal Reddy as Juror #6 Jo Young as Juror #3 Christopher Harrod as Juror #4 Shannon Moore as Juror #5 Maryann Towne as Colleen Dworkin Johnny Bermudez as Police Officer