Guest Stars Bryce Lorenzo as Hailey Hansen Christopher Fitzgerald as Sonny Shine Gus Halper as Mikey Scaramucci Joseph D. Reitman as Very Bad Santa Ren Colley as Kenji Co Starring Quentin Morales as Cal Jamie Kelton voices Bo Peep Katie Beth Hall as Brooke Alexander Jameson as Noah Benjamin Snyder as Chris Wick Samantha Bishop as Beth Luke Slattery voices Sock Puppet Lily Buchanan as Jamie Jack Cotterell voices Nutcracker Will McInerney as Benjamin Peters Brian Ogilvie as Lenny Donnelly George Letrell as Prison Guard