Guest Stars Philippa Domville as Martha Riley Arnold Pinnock as Victor Teach Grant as Preston Riley Nola Augustson as Della Paul Rae as Melvin Stubbs Bradley Stryker as Tanner Timothy V. Murphy as Gram Turner Juan Javier Cárdenas as Lew Nez Hannah Masi as Cynthia Rainey Co Starring Rohan Mead as Sam Riley Jr. David Haysom as Deputy Raymond Berryman Alexis McKenna as Brittany Butler Vicky Lambert as Gayle James Patrick Garrow as Eddie Heffernan Morgan David Jones as John Dyson Joe-Norman Shaw as Bill Dell Sasha Barry as Tina Barb Mitchell as Gloria Calhoun Tyler James as Tyrus Peter Hall as Wyoming Sheriff Andrew Cooper as Townsperson Greg Zach as Trench Club Wielder Greg Lawson as Reverend Alistair Rainey