Guest Stars Usman Ally as Hook-Handed Man Matty Cardarople as Henchperson of Indetermined Gender Nathan Fillion as Jacques Snicket Sara Canning as Jacquelyn Patrick Breen as Larry Your-Waiter Cleo King as Eleanora Poe Carol Mansell as Elder Jemma Ken Jenkins as Elder Sam Mindy Sterling as Elder Anabelle Kevin Chamberlin as Man in Plaid Pants Lossen Chambers as Mrs. Morrow Ithamar Enriquez as Hector Co Starring Jacqueline Robbins as White Faced Woman #1 Joyce Robbins as White Faced Woman #2 John DeSantis as Bald Man