Guest Stars James Lesure as FBI Agent Jim Turner Zach Gilford as Greg David Hornsby as Leslie "Boomer" Peterson Sally Pressman as Nancy Allison Tolman as Mary Pat Robert Jumper as Eddy Co Starring Mila Middleswarth as Jane Boland Kaitlyn Oechsle as Emma Boland Sutton Johnston as Danny Boland Braxton Bjerken as Kenny Boland Carlos Aviles as Mick Caleb Emery as Baby Tyler Jayvo Scott as Dags Kelsi Gumport as Heaven Lauren Revard as Housewife #3 Maurie Chandler as Heather Nirvi Bhargava as Housewife #1 Paul Brian Johnson as Police Officer #1 Matthew Barnes as Super Hip Waiter Stephen Ruffin as Agent Tom Peters Kathleen Hogan as Jewelry Saleswoman Dustin Lewis as Snobby Salesman