Guest Stars Corinne Massiah as May Grant Marcanthonee Jon Reis as Harry Grant Tracie Thoms as Karen Wilson Gavin Stenhouse as Priest Jennifer Aspen as Lorraine Alex Solowitz as Barry Johnson Todd Williams as Aaron Chester Brooks Dana Davis as Carrie Lex Medlin as Sean Coopertino Bree Turner as Sarah Jackson Hurst as Dan Ivar Brogger as Dr. Irving Co Starring Herbert Russell as Arborist Louis Tomeo as Adam Brian Maillard as Bill Matthew Jones as Zoo Sharp Shooter James Moses Black as Carl Peters Andy Hoff as Bartender Patrick Quinlan as Steven Marcy Goldman as Woman Ryan Quinn Smith as Eric Audrey Dundee Hannah as Reporter #2 Andrew Boyle as Reporter #1 Ru Kumagai as Fitness Employee