Guest Stars Roger Cross as Officer Wentworth Jason Gray-Stanford as Officer Eggers Alex Carter as Chief Strong Sharon Taylor as Diana Eggers Erin Chambers as Anna Strong Co Starring Emma Oliver as Emily Strong Kwesi Ameyaw as Judge Sean Campbell as Officer Sean Michael Q. Adams as Pastor Philip Cabrita as Townsperson #1 John Perrotta as Bailiff Keith Arbuthnot as Mr. Chuckleteeth Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez as Andrew Eggers Ken Godmere as Melvin Peter Monique Durian as Townsperson #2