Guest Stars Jazzy Williams as Anna Baker Deborah Hedwall as Judge Tia Hancock Erin Dilly as AUSA Hartman Nikki M. James as Chloe Talbott Sam Gilroy as Garrett Gatewood Patrick O'Neill as Isaiah Sims Co Starring Rachel Paula Green as Juror #17 John Wu as Juror #6 Ramona Floyd as Federal Magistrate Verlon Brown as Bailiff #2 Emily Behny as Juror #1 Mitzi Akaha as Bridget Means Holly Holcomb as Jessa Northop Melvin Lima as Juror #13 Johnny Biehle as Baliff Omar Corominas as Guard Robert Bryson as Jury Foreman Tom Martin as Thomas Hill