Guest Stars James Lesure as FBI Agent Jim Turner Zach Gilford as Greg David Hornsby as Leslie "Boomer" Peterson Allison Tolman as Mary Pat Co Starring Mila Middleswarth as Jane Boland Kaitlyn Oechsle as Emma Boland Sutton Johnston as Danny Boland Braxton Bjerken as Kenny Boland Danny Boyd Jr. as Harry Hill Caleb Emery as Baby Tyler Marcus Bailey as Car Salesman John Crow as Third Local Newscaster Nasir Rahim as Officer #2 Kelly Tippens as Customer #1 Kelly O'Neal as Second Local Newscaster Maia Moss-Fife as Transplant Coordinator Maurice Johnson as Officer #3 Stephanie Dunnam as Sally Clark Sarullo as Norma Peters (ER Doctor) Matt Myers as Customer #2 Drew Youngblood as Mary Pat's Son George Bryant II as Local Newscaster