Guest Stars Morena Baccarin as Dr. Leslie Thompkins Peter Scolari as Commissioner Loeb Dashiell Eaves as Kelly Milo Ventimiglia as Jason Lennon Colm Feore as Dr. Francis Dulmacher David O'Hara as Reggie Payne Barbara Rosenblat as Lidia Bicchieri Willa Fitzgerald as Grace Fairchild Brendan Griffin as Officer Len Moore Phillip James Griffith as The Catcher Co Starring Alex Corrado as Gabe Sean Ringgold as Clint Brendan Burke as Bugsy Desi Oakley as Antonia Alaska McFadden as Female Bartender Dan Domenech as Guitar Player