Guest Stars Kelly O'Sullivan as Valentina "Voodoo" Dunacci Kirsten Fitzgerald as Kathy "Mac" McMenimen Maura Kidwell as Claire "Stats" Bender Emily Peterson as Maeve Lenny Clarke as Johnny's Dad Ashleigh LaThrop as Gabby John Scurti as Theresa's Dad Nora Dunn as Bridget Lucas VonKampen as Kid #1 Guy Van Swearingen as Cop Bryan Kelly as White Sox Guy Christopher Meister as Cubs Fan Jonah Rawitz as Carter Iymen Chehade as Doctor #3 Liam Gade as Kid #2