Guest Stars DJ Qualls as Agent Rudy Fleckner Dan Lauria as Joe Moretti Shane Coffey as D. J. Pierce Robert Curtis Brown as Dr. Josiah Rosenthal Christopher Gartin as Father Pat Lisa Brenner as Tasha Ogden Marcia Ann Burrs as Lady at Reception Deniz Akdeniz as Jesse Branson Jonathan Slavin as Kevin Elizabeth McLaughlin as Cressida Gardner Klea Scott as CPD Detective Alisha Wainwright as Chantal Douglas Hannah Kasulka as Lily Williams David Chisum as Professor Gardner Susan Diol as Mrs. Gardner Co Starring Donald Agnelli as Judge Peter McAlpine Jack Forbes as Officer Randolph