Guest Stars Lachlan Watson as Susie Putnam / Theo Gavin Leatherwood as Nicholas Scratch Abigail F. Cowen as Dorcas Alessandro Juliani as Dr. Cerberus Christopher Rosamond as Mr. Kinkle Adrian Hough as Joe Putnam Bronson Pinchot as George Hawthorne Co Starring Anastasia Bandey as Dorothea Putnam Reese Alexander as Reverend James Walker Aadila Dosani as Doctor Guy Christie as Mr. Morris