Guest Stars Alia Attallah as Athena Rich Sommer as Harlan Emple Brandon J. Dirden as Agent Polk Isabel Arraiza as Lily Zavala Jeanette Dilone as Romy Alton Fitzgerald White as Lloyd Stephen Schnetzer as Eli Steven M. Robertson as Adam Braun Ned Eisenberg as Marvin Hathaway Siobhan Fallon as Sylvia Kozar Co Starring Susan Varon as Bingo Host