Guest Stars Carlo Marks as David Peck Abbie Magnuson as Caitlyn Winters Kayden Magnuson as Carrie Winters Jessica Sipos as Sarah Mercer Brittany Willacy as Leigh Corley Oliver Rice as Simon Atwater Michael Karl Richards as Wes Winters Bradley Stryker as John Rawl Tom Butler as Lawrence Riley Antonio Cayonne as Jordan Wilder Arielle Tuliao as Sierra Van Gheem Kate Isaac as Terri Ingram Nathan Witte as Tommy Eman Deborah Finkel as Head Judge Patti Allen as Dorothy McNamara