Guest Stars Sutton Foster as Tara Parker Lisa Emery as Mrs. Barnes Arian Moayed as Yusuf Al Shamsi Paul Urcioli as Jonah Chait Danny Boushebel as Rashid Musharakh Dorothy Lyman as Belinda Tony Crane as Everett Keck Patch Darragh as Griffin Parker Kevin O'Rourke as Deputy Commissioner Pat Martin LaPlatney as Darryl Ghent Tyler Lansing Weaks as Officer Hayes Frank Vlastnik as Handwriting Expert Adam Sietz as Rick David Michael Garry as Hugo