Special Guest Stars Matt Ryan as John Constantine Paul Reubens voices Mike the Spike Guest Stars Adam Tsekhman as Agent Gary Green Thomas F. Wilson as Hank Heywood Christian Keyes as Neron Jane Carr as Fairy Godmother Christian Keyes as Desmond Jordyn Ashley Olson as Prudence Hawthorne Co Starring Vesna Ennis as Garima, Queen of Thanzanon Jocelyn Panton as Marilyn Monroe Wesley MacInnes as Red Aaron Joseph as Drunk Man Glenn Williams as Puppeteer #3 Jeny Cassady as Puppeteer #1 Jamie Swettenham as Puppeteer #2