Guest Stars Matt Hobby as Pastor Jeff Hodgkins Wyatt McClure as Billy Sparks Ryan Phuong as Tam Nguyen Nancy Linehan Charles as Peg Isabel May as Veronica Duncan Jason Alexander as Mr. Gene Lundy Katherine Von Till as Anchor Adam Kulbersh as Fred Murphy Dale Raoul as Melissa Sara Sanderson as Leslie Joy Jacobson as Actress Shane Blades as Actor #2 Kirk Bovill as Actor #1 Hilda Boulware as Judy