Guest Stars Joe Grifasi as Judge Arlen Rand E.J. Bonilla as Gabriel Quinn Shephard as Tally North Chinasa Ogbuagu as ADA Kelly Scrivener Sterling Jerins as Young Tally Alan Aisenberg as Blake Lambert Co Starring Lynne Taylor as Dr. Diposo Stuart Zagnit as Potential Juror #11 / Jury Foreperson Julie Jesneck as Potential Juror #7 Jett Salazar as Cashier Robert Thackery as Torin North