Guest Stars Anthony Lemke as Detective Greyson Natalie Brown as Bessie Starkman Vincent Walsh as Coach Dutch Cunningham Amanda Barker as Eileen "Redwood" Richardson Michael Goldlist as Brody Co Starring John Koensgen as Dr. Peter Thomson Massimo Cannistraro as Dario Romano Amanda Richer as Viola Kelly Sean Kavenaugh as Umpire Nigel Downer as Bartender Candice Mausner as Evelyn Dawson Candice Lidstone as Dorothy Lloyd