Guest Stars Maggie Lawson as Natalie Flynn Nishi Munshi as Erica Malick Jonathan Sadowski as Andrew Simon Anna Khaja voices Senator Donna Malick Jay Acovone as Elliot Nunziata Costas Mandylor as Fabrizio Stavos Sandra Purpuro as Jill Brown Co Starring Geri-Nikole Love as Shana Beth Curry as Marcy Ian McLaren as Jimmy "Blinky" Doherty Jennifer Karen Lee as Wendy Fred Mancuso as Tony Corsetti Tim Doiron as Tow Truck Guy