Guest Stars Chance Hurstfield as Daniel "Danny" Dixon Ron Livingston as Jonathan "Jon" Dixon Jordan R. Coleman as Kevin Watkins Natasha Leggero as Woman in Line Co Starring Neil Webb as Keith Cameron Crosby as Teddy Graham Vincent Jones as Drummer Evelyn Burke as Young Sophie Chris Shields as Dr. Ehrlich Danny Dworkis as Man Trent Redekop as Christmas Tree Guy Taz Vanrassel as Bryce