Guest Stars Matt Hobby as Pastor Jeff Hodgkins Ryan Phuong as Tam Nguyen Sarah Baker as Ms. Cheryl Hutchins Isabel May as Veronica Duncan Paul Fusco voices Alf Co Starring Brian Chenoweth as Prayer Group #4 Joyce Greenleaf as Prayer Group #2 Bunnie Rivera as Prayer Group #1 Anthony S. Johnson as Prayer Group #3 Jaxy Boyd as Prayer Group #5 Uncredited Christopher Carrington as Dealer