Guest Stars Jake Abel as Trey Joelle Carter as Denise Meehan-Shepard John Getz as Doctor Dwight Giorgia Whigham as Teenage Denise Shea Whigham as William Meehan John Rubinstein as Old William Joshua Bassett as Teenage John Larry Sullivan as Dave Canova Co Starring Seneca Paliotta as Young Denise Holger Moncada, Jr. as Waiter John Zderko as Dano John Barbolla as Ed Anthony Lapenna as Young John Jasper Salon as ER Nurse #1 Cleta Ellington as Drunk Driver Brenda Lee as ER Nurse #2
