Special Guest Stars Henry Thomas as Dr. Charles McNider / Dr. Mid-Nite Guest Stars Joel McHale as Sylvester Pemberton / Starman Neil Hopkins as Lawrence "Crusher" Crock / Sportsmaster Joy Osmanski as Paula Brooks / Tigress Eric Goins as Steven Sharpe / The Gambler Hina Khan as Anaya Bowin / The Fiddler Mark Ashworth as Janitor Justin / Shining Knight Brian Stapf as Ted Grant / Wildcat Lou Ferrigno Jr. as Rex Tyler / Hourman Joe Knezevich as William Zarick / The Wizard Co Starring Stella Smith as Artemis Crock Max Frantz as Isaac Bowin Ashley Winfrey as Jenny Williams Jasun Jabbar as Brian Tanner Balloid Wil Deusner as Joey Zarick Sam Brooks as Travis Thomas Christian Adam as Josh Hamman Ashani Roberts as Charlotte Balogh Suehyla El-Attar as Mrs. Patterson Elizabeth Bond as Maggie Kramer Annie Thurman as Mary Kramer Julia Armitage as Town Girl Maizie Smith as Courtney @5 Olivia Baughn as Mary @5