Special Guest Stars Bobby Cannavale as Angie "AJ" Geils Jr. Guest Stars Taran Killam as Pierre Cardin Tony Cavalero as Timmy Rhodes Co Starring Katie O'Grady as Local Woman Ted Rooney as Bank Teller Eric Newsome as Dale Rigley Jason Rouse as Willy Porter Brian Koch as Thomas Fitz McSorley Mark Fullerton as Carl Donaldson Betty Moyer as Darlene Rigley