Guest Stars Tim Bagley as Toby Pearson Ryan Caltagirone as Hot Dad Patricia Belcher as Mavis Kelly Frye as Gina Meyers David Wain as Pastor Ted Ed Begley Jr. as John-Paul Bennigan Alley Mills as Joanna Bennigan Co Starring Jay Martel as Mr. Spinnoli Krishna Smitha as Melany Arianna Ortiz as Mrs. Gower Lily D. Moore as Lauren Jonny Berryman as Freddy Reuben Dodd as Michael Mahrynn McLaughlin as Erica