Guest Stars Erica Gimpel as Trisha Gaius Charles as Rev. Andrew Carver Charles Brice as Cal Davis Antonio Cipriano as Derrick Gomez CC Sabathia as Himself Co Starring Robert McKay as Lester Eddie K. Robinson as Tom Christopher Carley as Pete Garrity Juri Henley-Cohn as Teammate Erika Rolfsrud as Dayna Chessin Kim Ramirez as Bianca Gomez Jeff Sanders as Assistant Coach