Guest Stars Meghan Treadway as Belle Eliza Riley as Kelly Rebecca Scroggs as Abigail Reese Katharine Bennett-Fox as Cheryl Alan Davies as Dan Proctor Steven Pacey as Robert Frost Amy Huberman as Celina Pope Dan Mersh as Policeman Rebecca Root as Allie Greggs Dean Nolan as Man in the Beer Garden Rose Johnson as Rose Nicole Gibson as Koko Tyler Luke Cunningham as James