Guest Stars Jordana Blake as Hannah Edie Inksetter as Aunt Elizabeth Amy Landecker as Mrs. Mackenzie Ordena Stephens-Thompson as Martha Frances Scott Baker as Jonathan Alex Spencer as DCBS Officer Sarah Slywchuk as Handmaid Sarah Gale as Aunt Louise Caleb Ellsworth-Clark as Guardian #1 Heather Dicke as Staffer Danielle Ayow as Dr. Chung